Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
Info
FAQ

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn

"Your Local Family Operated Business For Over Thirty Five Years"

About Us

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn, located in St. Augustine, has been the area’s trusted destination since 2008, proudly serving surrounding communities with over 35 years of industry experience and more than 60 years of combined expertise. Known for having one of the largest selections of fine gold, platinum, and silver jewelry—including an impressive collection of estate jewelry—our spacious showroom also features rare coins and paper currency dating prior to 1930, as well as sought-after guitars from brands like Gibson and Fender, and a quality inventory of firearms. We offer free verbal appraisals, giving you the confidence to walk in, get your items evaluated, and walk out with cash—we pay more so you walk out with more. Whether you’re buying, selling, or trading, our knowledgeable team is dedicated to providing exceptional value, a seamless experience, and unmatched expertise in jewelry and estate buying.

Our Story

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn, located in St. Augustine, has been a trusted, family-owned destination for over 35 years, proudly serving the surrounding communities since opening in 2008. Built on decades of combined expertise, we have earned a reputation for honesty, value, and an unmatched selection of high-quality merchandise. Customers choose us not only for what we sell, but for how we serve—offering a straightforward, rewarding experience every time you walk through our doors.

We specialize in fine gold, platinum, and silver jewelry, featuring one of the largest selections of owned jewelry and estate jewelry in the area. From timeless classics to one-of-a-kind estate finds, our inventory is carefully curated to offer both beauty and value. In addition to jewelry, we carry a unique collection of rare coins and paper currency dating prior to 1930, making us a standout destination for collectors and history enthusiasts alike. Our showroom also includes premium guitars from iconic brands like Gibson and Fender, along with a quality selection of firearms for buyers seeking reliability and performance.

What truly sets Olde City Jewelry & Pawn apart is our commitment to giving customers the best return on their valuables. We offer free verbal appraisals, allowing you to walk in, get your items evaluated, and walk out with cash—quickly and confidently. We pay more so you walk out with more cash, ensuring every transaction is fair, transparent, and worthwhile. Whether you’re selling estate jewelry, vintage currency, instruments, or firearms, our experienced team provides accurate evaluations and competitive offers on the spot.

Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or trade, Olde City Jewelry & Pawn delivers a seamless and customer-focused experience backed by decades of industry knowledge. Visit us today and discover why we’re known as one of the area’s most trusted names for fine jewelry, estate pieces, and valuable assets.

Areas Served

Our Certifications

ATF Licensed
Cerified ANA Coin Specialist On-Site
Full Time Certified Numismatist
GIA Accredited

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Cash Loans
Jewelry Repair and Fabrication
Watch Batteries- $10 or 2 for $18

Our Services include:

Pawn Shop
Collateral Loans
Quick Cash
Gold and Scrap Buyers
In-House Jewelry Repair, Including:
* Shank work (including soldering, ring sizing, mounting assembly and installing).
* All prong work (including retipping and replacing prongs).
* Stone setting (including tightening, channel set, bezel set, bead set, pave' set and bright cutting).
* Finishing (including plating, epoxy, polishing & clean ring, satin finish and Florentine finish).
* Chain repairs/soldering (including advanced chain repair, basic chain repair, chain braiding with soldering, jump ring solder and charm soldering).
* Clasp repair (including spring rings, lobster claw, hidden clasp, box clasp and barrel clasp).
* Pearl repair (including knotted restringing, restring without knots, drill pearl and glue pearl).
* Engraving (including simple ring engraving [inside or out], lighters, trophies, nameplates, and many more items).
* Earring repair (including soldering post, screw-back and post conversion, lever-back drop conversion and converting bracelet link to earring conversion).
* Fabrication (including rebuilding bezel, seat and channel sets, gold link rebuilding, gold link addition/removal and bail repair).
* Platinum (basic and advanced platinum welding and ring sizing).
* Miscellaneous (including fabrication, gold testing and diamond testing).
* Watch link removal, battery replacement, and crystal replacement.
* Custom design work.
* Plating: Rhodium, 14-k Gold, Nickel Plating availableIn addition to our repair services, we offer In-House Custom Design Jewelry.

Our Brands include:

Colt
FN
Mossberg
Sig
Samsung
Compaq
Lenovo
LG
Dell
HP
Toshiba
Apple
Sony
HCL

Our Products include:

Glocks, Pistols, Rifles and Revolvers
Hand, Long and Shot Guns
Jewelry, Estate and Antique Jewelry
Gold, Silver and Platinum
Engagement, Wedding and Anniversary Bands
Solitaire, Cluster, Round, Princess and Halo Diamonds
Gold Chains and Bracelets
Diamond Earrings
Art
Coins, Silver Dollar, Silver Eagle, Krugerrand, Liberty and Indian Coins
Guitars

Testimonials

On 5/5/2026 Cary Garrett had this to say:
I've actually grown to love this place, everyond is so friendly and kind. My husband and I chose a ring in 2021 that we both fell in love with it is a beautiful peice of jewelry. Well being active moving and cleaning there have been twice I lost a diamond. They fixed it one year before Christmas and didn't charge a boat load of money and this time I lost 2 diamonds moving being rough with my jewelry knowing I should have taken them off again they took care of me. Always with smiles and laughter! they lent me a band to wear while getting my ring fixed. That is the kind of people they are. Just lovely! Makes me want to put down my purse and start working ☺️ Y'all are amazing!Don't forget it.. tTgere is a bigger picture and I think you guys see it.. it's all about the people and some amazing finds along the way. Thank you 😊

On 4/28/2026 Randy L. had this to say:
The service and friendliness are first class. We met Joel and he was wonderful in assisting us. Never having dealt in coins and gold he was very good at explaining what was important to look for. Thank you Joel and old city jewelry and pawn

On 4/13/2026 Patricia Buchinsky had this to say:
Great experience at this local family business. Transparent process to evaluate the things I brought in. Very satisfied.

On 4/1/2026 Susan Krawczyk, Realtor had this to say:
I can’t recommend this place enough! While it’s a pawn shop, they are hands down the best jeweler in the area. Their jewelry selection is stunning and curated, and you truly cannot beat their fair prices. What really sets them apart is the atmosphere—it is family-owned, and you can feel that the moment you walk in. The staff is incredibly friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable. If you're looking for quality pieces without the typical retail markup, this is the spot!

On 3/31/2026 donna calandra had this to say:
Great silver and coins

Contact Us

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn
2590 US Highway 1 South St. Augustine, FL 32086
Phone: (904) 797-7296
Mobile: (904) 587-9806
Email: info@oldecitypawn.com

1/2 Mile South of Walmart - Opposite Side of the Road

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, & Ca$h!

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 3:30 PM

Info

Shop Our Ebay!
Shop Our Etsy!
Flyer

FAQ

How does buying and selling at Olde City Jewelry & Pawn work?

Our process is simple and transparent. Customers can walk in, browse items for sale, or have their valuables professionally evaluated. If you choose to sell, you’ll receive an offer on the spot; if you’re buying, our staff is available to answer questions and help you find the right piece.

What makes Olde City Jewelry & Pawn different from other pawn shops?

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn stands apart due to its large selection of fine jewelry and estate jewelry, knowledgeable evaluations, and fair pricing for both buyers and sellers. We also have a certified ANA (American Numismatic Association) coin specialist on site, ensuring expert care and accurate evaluations for rare coins, historic currency, and collectibles. Whether you are purchasing jewelry, coins, guitars, or firearms—or having items appraised—our focus is on expertise, transparency, and long‑term trust.

Can I get a free appraisal even if I’m not selling?

Absolutely. We provide free verbal appraisals whether you’re considering selling now or just want to know the value of your jewelry, coins, or collectibles. There is never any pressure to sell. You also can walk out of the store with cash if you are ready to make the sale!

What types of jewelry does Olde City Jewelry & Pawn sell?

Olde City Jewelry & Pawn offers a wide selection of fine gold jewelry, platinum jewelry, and silver jewelry, including estate and vintage pieces. Our inventory frequently includes one‑of‑a‑kind items, classic designs, and high‑quality craftsmanship at competitive prices.

Do you sell estate and vintage jewelry?

Yes. We are known for carrying a large selection of estate jewelry and vintage jewelry, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, and unique heirloom pieces. Estate jewelry offers exceptional value and character, making it a popular choice for collectors and everyday wear.

Why is estate jewelry a good option for buyers?

Estate jewelry often features higher-quality materials and craftsmanship than modern mass‑produced pieces. Shopping estate jewelry allows buyers to find unique designs, vintage styles, and luxury materials at exceptional value.

Do you also buy gold, jewelry, and valuables?

Yes. In addition to selling, we buy fine gold, platinum, and silver jewelry, as well as estate jewelry, coins, guitars, and firearms. We offer free verbal appraisals so customers understand the value of their items before making a decision

Can I buy coins and historic paper currency at your store?

Yes. Olde City Jewelry & Pawn sells coins and paper currency dated pre‑1930, including collectible silver and gold coins and historic currency. Availability varies, but our selection often includes rare and investment‑grade items sought after by collectors.

Do you sell Gibson and Fender guitars?

We carry Gibson and Fender guitars, including electric and acoustic models. Our guitar inventory may include vintage, collectible, and professional‑grade instruments, making us a destination for musicians and collectors alike.

Are firearms available for purchase?

Yes. Olde City Jewelry & Pawn sells firearms in accordance with all local, state, and federal laws. Inventory changes frequently, and all purchases follow required legal procedures to ensure safety and compliance.